teknotum
Skip to content

Teknotum

Court rejects free speech rights for AI chatbots — for now

Can an AI be sued for the wrongful death of a young teen to suicide? Or do they have free speech rights? A trial will now decide.
A young teen was allegedly encouraged into suicide. Now the question is whether an AI chatbot can be held accountable. (Picture: Character.ai)
In a Florida court case that could one day define First Amendment rights for AI, a judge has declined to consider the defendant’s arguments for dismissal — setting the stage for a trial showdown over whether AI chatbots are faulty products or entities entitled to rights previously reserved for humans.

The case revolves around a teen whom Character.ai allegedly encouraged into suicide over a long interaction, and whether the developers should be held accountable for his tragic death, in a wrongful death lawsuit.

Malfunction machine, or a free mind?
The defendants, Google and Character.ai have filed for a summary dismissal on the grounds that chatbots have free speech rights, which are protected under law.

The plaintiff, the teen’s mother, argued that they made a flawed product they can be held liable for.

The U.S. Senior District Judge Anne Conway presiding did not rule on the actual merits of this argument, saying instead that she is «not prepared» to hold that the chatbots’ output constitutes speech «at this stage,» but denied the motion to dismiss.

Real battle looming
This means the case will go ahead to a full trial, setting up a legal showdown on just how much freedom and responsibility AI systems can be assigned — if any.

— The order certainly sets it up as a potential test case for some broader issues involving AI, said Lyrissa Barnett Lidsky, a law professor at the University of Florida, to The Associated Press.

The developers of the chatbot said ruling against free speech rights for AI bots will have a «chilling effect» for the entire industry.

Read more: Court report from The Associated Press, The Washington Post has details on the conversations with the chatbot.

Author Tor FosheimPosted on 23. May 202523. May 2025Tags AI, google, law

Post navigation

Previous Previous post: Anthropic claims world’s best coding AI with Claude 4 Opus and Sonnet
Next Next post: Pitting humans against AI at FrontierMath yields mixed results

You might also like

Timbaland’s next pop starlet is an AI avatar

AIFF, the AI Film Festival, showcases innovative video, as industry set to pounce

OpenAI’s Codex now available to ChatGPT Plus users

Anthropic CEO says it’s time to wake up on AI job losses

Big Tech stops hiring new graduates, as entry level jobs dry up

Court rejects free speech rights for AI chatbots — for now

From the front page

New vaccine combines nanotech and mRNA to eradicate pancreatic cancer

09:11 15 Jun 2025

Yes, there’s an AI ad out there — but the tech can do so much more

10:17 14 Jun 2025

Google Workspace now auto-summarizes PDFs for you

09:04 14 Jun 2025

Google experiments with audio overviews in Search results

08:48 14 Jun 2025

Meta invests $14.3 billion in infrastructure company Scale AI, rivals leaving

06:39 13 Jun 2025

Adobe advertising AI airplanes anthropic apple bard cancer chatgpt climate coding copyright defense drones energy facebook film game gemini google images instagram internet iphone law llama media meta Microsoft military netflix nvidia openai playstation research romfart science search sony sosiale medier streaming TV twitter vaccines work

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
  • About teknotum
  • Newsletter
Teknotum Manually edited with WordPress